The wealth of kings
We look at a radical suggestion concerning the Sun King.
In the library of our consultant with too many books is a bound set of The Spectator, a sort of early newspaper column (and thus a precursor to the blog). In No. 200 a correspondent makes a rather startling suggestion: the wars of Louis XIV of France, then just concluding, had actually made that monarch poorer. Not through the crippling taxation required to build up and maintain his armies, nor the expenses of the wars themselves, nor through the enmity of almost all the other countries in Europe, but because he now ruled fewer people. (It was not so much the soldiers he’d lost in decades of war, as the famine and disease that the wars had left in their wake.)
This was (and is) a radical idea. The Sun King had extended the frontiers of France significantly, so by the standards of the time he must have made his kingdom richer, for land was the measure of the wealth of a kingdom. In an age where the economy was still overwhelmingly agricultural the equation must clearly still hold. And it had the weight of thousands of years of history behind it. The great wanderings of the Dark Ages (to go no further back) were all in search of land. The whole feudal system was built on the idea that land was wealth. Clearly the acquisition of many more square toises would make Louis richer, and allow him to reward his faithful followers handsomely in the best feudal manner.
But the Spectator, an Englishman, suggests two thought-experiments: first, simply remove the inhabitants of London. Queen Anne would immediately see a much reduced flow of tax money into her coffers. She would be the poorer in spite of having lost not a square yard of land. Conversely, duplicating London would increase the monarch’s income greatly with negligible change of the kingdom’s area. Second, suppose a new edition of the British Isles were to appear, say rising out of the Atlantic to the west, and become the undisputed property of the Queen. The new land would be worthless until people went there to work it, thereby reducing the activity in the old part of the kingdom; it might even be a net loss.
One can argue with many of the details of the Spectator’s assertions, especially if one takes into account periodic overpopulation in a pre-industrial society and the contributions of the overseas colonies that England and France both had at the time. But certainly historic examples of a loss of population showed that nations became poorer when it happened. There was the Black Death in the fourteenth century, the expulsion of the Jews and the Moors from Spain in the sixteenth and seventeenth, and Louis’ own edict to his Protestant subjects to convert or leave. Conversely, the Huguenots that made their way to England contributed measurably to the latter kingdom’s economy.
So maybe we should think of all the refugees living in camps around the world today not as a problem, but as a potential source of wealth for whichever ruler is willing to take them in. Our Spectator indeed considered something of the sort in his time. But he concluded that his xenophobic countrymen would never allow unchecked immigration and England would have to make do with only its natural increase of population.

No Comments