Where or who do you belong?
Your passport is the product of a legal fiction.
Last week we mentioned the idea that the wealth of a king was derived not from the land (the size or richness thereof) but from the people he could count as subjects. By this measure Louis XIV of France would have done better to forego any conquest of new provinces and simply attract to his crown more people. Pushing this a little farther, he might count as “his” anyone who would acknowledge his rule (and, we suppose, agree to pay his taxes). He would be a king of the French, rather than of France.
There is nothing completely new about this. The idea that on one side of a line everyone is a Frenchman, speaking French, acting French, worshiping in a Catholic church and descended from a Frenchman; and on the other, everyone is similarly and separately German, is a fiction of the nineteenth century. Historians of that era were occupied in finding the earliest trace of the “true” national identity so as to establish the moral superiority of their particular nation-state. The tribes of the Age of Migration were conceived as unified groups of blood relatives in search of living space where they could achieve national greatness. They were no such thing. The Angles, Saxons and Jutes that invaded Britain were made up of anyone in a vague ethnic area who thought the leaders were onto a good thing; similarly those who followed Clovis into Gaul. Recent genetic work has shown, in particular, that there was no wholesale replacement of old blood by new in the former Roman provinces.
Indeed the first kings were kings “of the Franks” or “of the English” or whatever name they came up with. The Franks and others on the Continent were subject to a different law from that of the Gallo-Romans they had conquered, who were still considered Roman citizens. Much later, the Normans who conquered England (by then long past any division into Angles, Saxons and Jutes) were treated differently in law from the conquered people. For a while; by the time of the Magna Carta everyone, regardless of descent, was spoken of as English. (Though the speaking might take place in Norman French or Latin.)
The eventual unification into separate and sovereign kingdoms papered over an enormous diversity in customs, law and even language. Cardinal Richelieu, to drop a name with which you may be familiar, sought to impose a standard French upon a diversity of dialects which were not always even mutually intelligible. Similar efforts were carried out in other predecessors of the nation-states, in language and in other ways. (The diversity of laws in the various French duchies, counties, lordships and archbishoprics was not actually done away with until the Revolution. In Germany it lasted until after the First World War.) Unification was always a little uneasy and sometimes there was open rebellion.
So for historical and practical reasons the law of France came to apply to anyone within the land of France, regardless of what they called themselves; and the king of France came to regard everyone who lived in that land as his subjects and part of his wealth. And so for other countries. But maybe it would be a good idea to be able to declare to the king’s minions, “He is no king of mine! I am a Burgundian of the Empire.”

No Comments