The whole picture

Little stories

The picture is not complete without the details.

Some years ago our astronomer was scheduled to go to a conference in Prague.  He had not been to the area before, so he went to the library to find a history of Czechoslovakia, or Czechia, to get some background before he left.  The only ones he could find started in 1918, which was hardly any help for a land he knew had centuries of existence before that.  Neither were there books on Bohemia-and-Moravia, the political entity that the Czech lands had been.  Indeed, “bohemian” and “Moravian” have entirely different meanings in English dictionaries, with only curious historical connections with the geographic places.  To find out what happened there in the Middle Ages you have to tease details out of a history covering some much larger entity.

Europe is strewn with lands (and associated peoples) that ignore, or are ignored by, the nation-states that issue passports and have histories written about them.  They were more or less deliberately suppressed by nation-building in the Early Modern age, when constructing a unified France (for instance) meant breaking down the differences between Gascons, Aquitainians and Burgundians.  In other cases, they have shifted from one big country to another as political fortunes changed.  Silesia has been in turn Austrian, Prussian, Polish and other (depending on how you draw the border).  And sometimes peoples themselves have settled in new places, so as to be found across national borders; in the Balkans it’s extremely hard even to draw accurate maps.

History as seen by the small peoples (to use an awkward and not wholly accurate term) can look quite different from what we’re used to.  A Ukrainian found himself in the Polish army in 1939, and wound up being rescued by the Nazis from the Soviets; we’re not used to anyone with that background feeling grateful to them.  Another was saved from the Romanians by the Red Army, and would never after hear a word against Stalin.  A continuing source of trouble is that inevitably there will be Hungarians (for example) outside Hungary, unless that country is made very big, in which case there will be Romanians, Bulgarians, Ukrainians and others outside their countries.

These European examples are used because we’re familiar with them.  No doubt similar things have happened and are happening in, say, India and Indonesia, enormous collections of many different parts.  Someone who knows more than we do can fill in those details.

This matters more than just to those searching for relevant history books.  There are political motivations and fault-lines everywhere, invisible to eyes accustomed to the idea of a uniform nation-state.  And these days no part of the world is completely isolated from the rest.

Share Button

No Comments

Post a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.